Click to see the beacon journal online
Homes   Jobs   Cars   Shopping
Blog of Mass Destruction -- Community Blog

Previous post:

Next post:

Don't Believe GOP Lies About Mortgage Crisis

by The Reverend on October 10, 2008

in Uncategorized

From the beginning of the financial meltdown there has been a concerted effort by Republican types to divert the public's attention away from accusations that excessive deregulation created the mess we're now in.

These Republicans don't want to own up to their failed economic policies in the Congress the past 14 years, or their failed Republican presidental leadership in the field of economics, the presidency they have held 20 out of the last 28 years. Instead, they seek to blame….you guessed it….Democrats. The dynamic is perfectly understandable.

The phony viral meme to counter the truth of Republican deregulation goes like this:

Democrats, the alleged 'white guilt party', created our current financial meltdown by forcing financial institutions to give loans to poor minorities who weren't qualified. In this faux-version of reality, banks and lenders didn't want to give out trick, inflated interest rate and gimmick loans to non-qualifying applicants…but the government forced them into doing so. In the extreme version, by that I mean FOX news and various and sundry wingnut "reporters", Barack Obama and ACORN have been busy behind the scenes for years intentionally wrecking financial institutions by using 'white guilt' on their way to ushering in an age dominated by black liberation theology.

From this racist viewpoint, the fact that 60% of current foreclosures are coming from speculated homes whose loans were taken out by middle and upper middle class Americans looking to make a quick buck…..doesn't enter into the equation.

But what's the truth?

Partisan Republicans are trying to direct attention to Jimmy Carter's 1977 Community Reinvestment Act(CRA) as the culprit of our current problems. These same partisan Republicans point to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, government sponsored enterprises (GSE's), as also being the cause of our current problems.

This article should be read by those touting F & F or CRA as the source of our current problems.

Here are a few questions from that article…

1) Did the CRA legislation of 1977, or any legislation since, require banks to not verify income or payment history of mortgage applicants?

2) Were 'no money down' mortgages required by the CRA or Freddy and Fannie?

3) Did any federal legislation require real estate agents and mortgage writers to use the same corrupt appraisers again and again? How did these appraisers manage to always come in at exactly the purchase price, no matter what?

4) How exactly did legislation force Moody's, S&P's and Fitch to rate junk paper as Triple AAA?

5) Were banks required by Congress to do piggy back loans, one for the house, one for the downpayment, at the same time?

6) Internal bank memos showed employees how to cheat the system to get poor mortgage prospects approved that shouldn't have been, titled: "How to Get an Iffy loan approved at JPM Chase." Was this required by Congressional legislation?

7) The four biggest problem areas for housing are: Phoenix, Las Vegas, Miami, and San Diego. Explain how these affluent, non-minority regions were impacted by the Community Reinvestment Act?

8) Did Fannie and Freddie require banks to not check credit scores? Assets? Income?

Obviously, federal legislation doen't explain or answer any of those questions. Instead, it certainly appears that unfettered and unregulated financial institutions created their own problems.

The root legislative cause of the credit crisis was excessive deregulation. From exempting deriviatives from regulation (2000 Commodities Futures Modernization Act) to failing to adequately oversee ratings agencies that slapped a triple AAA on junk paper, the pendulum swung too far away from reasonable oversight. By taking the refs off the field and erroneously expecting market participants could self-regulate, the powers that be in D.C. gave the players on Wall Street enough rope to hang themselves with…..which they promptly did.

If you really want to understand how this meltdown happened and why, take a few minutes to read the following links.

Fed
Shrugged as Subprime Crisis Spread

Greenspan says ARMs might be better deal.

Subprime Suspects

Taking Hard new Look at a Greenspan Legacy

Examples of wingnut racism and homophobia over the meltdown….

Let's Move Wall Street

Cavuto blaming minorities

Frank says GOP housing attacks racially motivated

Fundamentalists blame Wall Street's woes on gays

  • mary

    from the website for responsible lending — between 1998 and 2006 15 million sub prime loans made — 9 % to first time home owners — 52 % were refinancings — 39 % were for second and investment homes and in fact in the conclusions of the report they state that sub prime loans resulted in a reduction in first time home ownership.

    An unrelated comment — to me the GOP is no longer the Grand Old Party. It has been hijacked by various groups– religious and otherwise. The GOP is no longer fiscally conservative — they spend even more that the Democrats and I could go on and on and on on how they no longer stand for the principals they expound. Perhaps we will ultimately find that the Democratic party is in the same shape but we do not at this time know that. I feel the Republican Party must evenually lose and break down so it can attempt to rebuild itself into the party that all of its members remember from the past. I do not understand how any Republican can be proud of what the party has become.

  • larry d.

    Yes bad loans were made to speculators. The question is why those bad loans were possible. The answer is bad loans were encouraged by the frauds on capitol hill.

  • The Reverend

    larry asserts that "bad loans were encouraged by the frauds on capitol hill".

    The only way I can understand an assertion like that is to equate "frauds on capital hill" to mean Congressional Republicans. From 1994 to 2006 Tom DeLay, Numbskull Newtie, Dennis Hastert, Dr. Frist, Phil Gramm and Wife, and a host of others from the extreme right ran roughshod over our economy with a no-holds-barred approach to any infringement on business or capital. Deregulation is a foundational doctrine of the Republican Party. Privatizing anything that moves. Ushering in voluntary, fingers crossed self-oversight. Just trust us and the divinities inherent in the freer than free market will lead all of us into some f*cking Wal-Mart Utopia.

    That Utopia currently looks like a huge sh*tpile.

  • larry d.

    I don't know, Rev. I seem to remember Maxine Waters lauding the 'creative' loan ideas good old Franklin was coming up with earlier this decade.

    That was during the hearing where Barney and the rest were accusing the regulator of being a racist. I'm sure you've seen the youtube video.

  • The Reverend

    No Democrats encouraged banks to cheat. No Republicans encouraged banks to cheat.

    Republicans saw their deregulation program through to completion…which created a situation where banks could cheat.

  • Da King

    I have worked for four different banks. All four were pressured by community organizer groups to reduce loan standards and make loans to unqualified persons. All four were vilified in the newspapers, since these community groups get lots of press. All four banks were called racist, and all four ultimately gave in to the pressure and started granting these "creative" loans. Banks are deathly afraid of bad press, because they are deathly afraid of runs on their bank. This shell game actually worked for a long time, because Fannie and Freddie were bundling and securitizing the loans (half of all the loans in the country), and investment banks were happy to buy up the loans, since the housing market was going up, up, up, for 30 years. But eventually, supply and demand caught up and the entire house of cards started collapsing. At the first warning signs, several Republicans took steps to regulate and reign in Fannie and Freddie, and the Democrats united to stop it, falsely calling the Republicans and even the Fannie-Freddie regulators racist. These are all factual statements that cannot be controverted.

    If the Reverend sees NO culpability of Democrats in the above scenario, well, that's what makes you the Reverend, and that's why you cannot be believed for one second.

    And Barney Frank should be expelled from Congress, at minimum. He is lying his butt off. He is the perfect example of what is wrong with our government. No accountability, always partisan, always deflecting blame away from himself by any means necessary.

    The Rev's statement that there is no regulation of banks could not be more wrong. There is tons of regulation, but the government took an active role in setting up the exact environment which led to the subprime crisis, on purpose.

    Has anyone noticed that Congress has not yet proposed even one NEW regulation ? In fact, Congress is doing precisely the opposite. They are attempting to reinflate the housing bubble again. They are readvocating the same policies that got us here in the first place.

  • The Reverend

    You're in a state of denial.

    I know that you must remain in a state of denial….or you must jettison your belief in a deregulated and unfettered market place as being sacrosanct.

    And once again King….to continue the false messaging that Democrats forced banks to give out loans without income verification and appraisals…..to continue to point to F&F as the problem….is not only factually dishonest…but also….sorry…morally dishonest.

    Greedy, deregulated money shuffling schemers created the mess we're in.

  • http://politics.ohio.com/ Ben Keeler

    Whats with posting the link about Frank saying the attacks were racially motivated? It is his own words?

  • The Reverend

    Frank said this…

    "They get to take things out on poor people," Frank said at a mortgage foreclosure symposium in Boston. "Let's be honest: The fact that some of the poor people are black doesn't hurt them either, from their standpoint. This is an effort, I believe, to appeal to a kind of anger in people."

    So you disagree with Frank when he says the kind of talk GOP'ers have been doing doesn't "appeal to a kind of anger in people"?

    Republicans are trying to place the blame on Democrats and poor minorities. The problem originated from deregulation.

    I used Frank's own words because they're true.

  • larry d.

    Frank's statement is a deflection. GOPers don't blame poor people–they blame him.

  • The Reverend

    GOP'ers would blame their mothers if it made them look better.

    And yes, GOP'ers do blame poor people….especially if they have darker hued skin.

  • Da King

    Yeah Rev, what would I know about why the banks did what they did in dropping loan standards ? I only witnessed it firsthand over a period of two-plus decades. I'm sure the political spin you have cribbed from the Dems is much more accurate, lol.

  • Da King

    Barney Frank is a liar and a hypocrite of the first order. Frank was resisting regulation of the mortgage industry until the house of cards he helped erect fell down, and now he's calling others racist because Frank KNOWS he is culpable. A truly despicable human being.

    And that's not partisan, it's just the truth.

Previous post:

Next post:

 

© The Akron Beacon Journal • 44 E. Exchange Street, Akron, Ohio 44308

Powered by WordPress
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).